Dissident Voice calls THE INVENTION OF THE JEWISH PEOPLE “earth-shattering.”

by admin on August 19, 2010

In a new piece today, Dissident Voice writes “Shlomo Sand argued with meticulous scholarship in his earth-shattering book, The Invention of the Jewish People, that the claim that the Jews of today are the ethnic offspring of the biblical Jews is yet another Zionist myth…”

The full article is here.

Share this page:
  • Facebook
  • Google Bookmarks
  • email
  • Twitter

{ 18 comments… read them below or add one }

Richard August 29, 2010 at 12:13 pm

Has mr. Sand researched the basis for the DNA tests that disprove his theory?

Especially it would be interesting to know, who is actually participating in this research – whose DNA is getting tested? Are offspring of “mixed” couples participating ? Are only religious jews participating ?

Mr sand said that:

“. As of today, no study based on anonymous DNA samples has succeeded in identifying a genetic marker specific to Jews, and it is not likely that any study ever will”

It would be interesting, if he could eloborate on it.

Oh, and one more thing: I can’t for the life of me understand the “anti-semite” accusation against Mr. Sand.

Claiming that most jews today are ancestors of European converts IS THE TOTAL OPPOSITE of anti-semitism. Most true anti-semites don’t like this theory at all.

Psalms 58 September 9, 2010 at 7:23 am

I’m glad the truth is being brought forth and that people finally start to realise what’s going on. The “Jews” in modern day Israel, or commonly known as the “State of Israel” are DESCENDANTS of the ancient Khazars. This is also explained in the book
“The Thirtheenth tribe” by Arthur Koestler. In other words, if these
“Jewish” people are indeed part of the biblical nation of Israel, then
they would have to be the 13th tribe, since the Bible tells us that Israel is comprised of only 12 tribes.

Gummel November 7, 2010 at 9:04 am

Without going into details: how the zionist historian can explain to us the ethnic difference between the falashas of ethiopia (black jews) and the ashkenaz jews or the sephardim jews? or for that matter the etnic difference between these latters and the Ashkenazim jews. We have here at least three different peoples (and I am even not speaking about the cultural differences). Actually, one can build up another jewish people absolutely similar to the present one. How? By picking up samples of non jews from the very regions where the jews settled all over the last centuries (middle europe, North africa, Africa, etc..). Come on, how can they (the zionist historians) be sure that all these racially, ethnically and culturally different peoples that make up the modern Israel, really originated from the Hebrews? Assuming that these hebrews had ever existed.

Judah April 5, 2011 at 10:36 pm

Sorry jerks, had my DNA tested. 100% semite cohen with DNA nearly identical to a Syrian or a Jordanian. And that is after 2000 years of exile from my homeland. Creating the lie that the Jews are not from the Land of Israel is a last ditch effort of the anti-Zionist and anti-semite to justify Arab violence.

Oh, and my wife has a family tree going back to King David with all the names. Sorry to burst your Jew-hating bubble.

Am Yisrael Chai!

Judah Nazura April 18, 2011 at 1:55 pm

thats impossible.. For anybody to be a Jew..first off..he d be living in misery becuz of Curses of Dueteronomy..for disobediance. 2nd..to back that up..no Jews/Israelites are supposed to be in the Land if Israel until the Most High gathers back all the tribes which are scattered thruout the world. The jews living in captivity in these days would not be practicing any form of judaism..becuz they would Worship the gods of the people who brought them to that country. It says israel is a Slave people..a people who lost their heritage and religion and history..but mimic the customs and practices of the people who Enslaved them. Yes..No one recognizes the jew as a jew..becuz the true jew the Torah tells us is a valley of dry bones..a Living people ..but not a Living nation..they are spiritially dead..the Lost Sheep of israel. theres no way u can be a jew..u live in Israel now, and u live comfortable,,blasphemy! African Americans are the true house of Israel

mary July 10, 2011 at 11:17 am

Saying that Israel is the homeland of all Jews is rather like saying all Catholics should go and occupy Rome as their homeland. It makes no sense and would only be an arguement taken up by people with nothing much better to do than pick a fight.

Beatrice August 24, 2011 at 8:17 am

It is truly sad to read the bible and trace back the history that the original Hebrews never mixed with any other tribe or very few intermarriages, so how did a black man Ibrahim begot white grand children when you read the bible with all the trace of black every where, as a white person I can see it, and for all these fools to miss this fact, they must have hired someone to help them not to see the biblical truth. Even with intermarriages they will not turn up this white people. the integrity of the Holy bible is compromised. Human being we have hit the rock bottom, even the so call Christians have perpetuate this lie. very deeply sadden.

judah nazura killa November 19, 2011 at 8:53 am

Judah nazura take your bitch made ass on somewhere hoe ass nigga. Ole yeh I’m still gonna beat your bitch ass faggot.

Watcher465 December 18, 2011 at 7:33 am

Richard please direct your stupid innuendo ridden question to Mr Sand not to us.
Judah, so you’ve been exiled from your homeland for 2000 years have you? Yet you seem to be coping after all that time of starving and surviving the pogroms, the holocaust etc. So where are you living now? In the land that you stole from the Palestinians or in the stately mansion that you were exiled to. And your wife is as big a liar as you are. She does not have a family tree dating back to king david because there never was a king david. She can only have a list of fictitious names and I’m sure she does. Keep on living in your psychopathic jewish dreamworld and dream up some more lies if it makes you happy but understand this. We know you are a liar!

Thomas December 18, 2011 at 10:18 pm

1.According to DNA genetics, the first human beings were in southern east africa.
2.And that all humans sare this same common gene which are in Africans.
3.That means the first humans were out of africa and were black reddish people.
4.According to the definition of hebrew in the bible or also ethiopian bible like book of Jubilee
the word hebrew means before the fall of babbel and that means all people spoke one language and it was hebrew .
5.Hebrew was the holy language spoken in garden eden which is in the bible sout of east africa.
6.White european jews as well as the other jews were before a black till brown colored people
until they mixed up with europeans.
7.Oure white jews are oure brother.
8.We must show them our love and intarmarry with them and be totally obedient to the Torah.
9.We must understand that Yah said to abraham that i gave you the land of israel from the nile
river till the euphretes river which has been our ancient convenant with yah Israel.Which is the entire east of Africa till even part of Southern Africa till saudi arabia and part of iran and so. look it up your self in the bible and compare with the map.
10.The africans came from ephramites leaders under the other tribe of israel.
11. Again we must mix up with the white Jews and be OBEDIENT TO THE LAW OF MOSES , SO THAT WE CAN ALSO INHERIT IT AND GLORIFY THE MOST HIGH.
12.Remember the prophecy of the end time said that race will fight against race. Let us learn from racisim and not be put to disgrace for it is written that yah will cast israel in all the 4 corners of the world.!

Rastus Postlethwaite March 23, 2012 at 6:35 pm

This actually is anti semite agument, ive read it before. But its still true The jews once used to prosletyse. That of course is why they are not a homogenous racial identity. Id guess that there are lots of egyptians, lebenese, jordanians and general people living in the levant area who can claim a greater lineage back to ancient kingdom of Judah and kingdom of Israel inhabitants than many of the european jews. Over the years youve had lots of intermarriage , even if its not evident today its obviously happened ergo the DNA record. A big melting pot. Still the crazies wont accept this.

IAM April 30, 2012 at 1:04 pm

A verifiable Control is needed to determine the Genetic origin of a group. Even if all the samples take from a particular group shows that the members of that group share a common ancestor,… without an verifiable Control to compare the samples with, there is no way to determine with certainty a specific genetic donor. In the case of Jewish males with last name “Cohen” sharing certain genetic markers showing a common paternal ancestor,… without an verifiable Control(DNA sample), from the remains of a priest from the temple era, then there is no way to determine that the Cohen common male ancestor was in fact a priest of the tribe of Levi and not a Convert to “Judaism” that changed his name to Cohen.
Excellent book!

dwarakanathfu August 20, 2012 at 7:02 am

for what

dwarakanathfu August 20, 2012 at 7:04 am

formelation

Sam Rivers April 4, 2013 at 12:39 am

It is historically correct that Ishmael and Issac lived in the same area with their father Abraham who taught them about his God. The children of Issac married the children of Ishmael their cousins with the blessing of Issac. Abraham himself was from the Chaldeans and a Bedouin. During the time of Islam there were large Arab tribes in Saudi Arabia who were Jewish by religion. The original Sons of Israel very likely converted to Islam as they are the same people Arabs.

dj April 15, 2014 at 7:15 pm

I dont underatand these kids. HOW FUCKTARDED YOU ARE CONVERTED CUNTS IF ,, JEW” WRITES ABOUT HIS ,,NATION” AND HE SAY ITS NOT NATION OR FOLK R THAT YOU CAME FRON YISRAEL HOLY LAND!? Fuck you, Arabs are true Semits and Hebrew is Ethiopian languagee dont need to mention Ladino and Yidish.Its not hate its true, thah you are terrifyed of! 60% of whole histoty,science and medicine is pure lie,deviant,modified,deleted lie which ee accepted.

Lynx May 20, 2014 at 10:56 am

Some 90 % (?) of jews today are ashkenazi, and ashkenazis are heavily southern european (“high degree of European admixture (30%-60%) among the Ashkenazi” Am Soc Hum Genet)

platter mikasa garden toscana November 30, 2014 at 12:58 pm

I know this site presents quality depending articles and additional
stuff, is there any other site which offers such information in quality?

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: